Most trouble with an Indian folio abroad is small and repeats: the wrong value, the wrong year, a missing account. Below are nine mistakes, each with the rule and the page to read, and the Pencil-Margin Proofread to run before anything is filed. We prepare U.S. returns and work with the holder's own adviser in India, Canada or the UK.
Nine mistakes and the rule behind each
| Mistake | What the rule says | Read |
|---|---|---|
| Skipping Form 8621 because the holding is small | The exception needs all PFIC stock at USD 25,000 or less (USD 50,000 joint) on December 31, no election, no excess distribution and no sale gain | 8621 guide |
| Leaving a folio off the FBAR | Folios, demat and NRE or NRO accounts are generally counted together toward USD 10,000. The rules do not name Indian folios, so this is the usual reading | FBAR and 8938 |
| Using one value for every form | FBAR: highest balance in the year. Form 8938: year-end or any-time limits. Form 8621 test: year-end. Canada's T1135: total cost, not value | T1135 guide |
| Mixing India's year with the calendar year | The USA and Canada use the calendar year, the UK April 6 to April 5, India April 1 to March 31 | Statements |
| Reporting rupees unconverted, or mixing rate sources | FBAR and Form 8938 use the Treasury rate for December 31 (₹89.854 per USD for 2025). Canada uses the Bank of Canada rate | Rate page |
| Assuming a SIP carries on after a move | Some fund houses stop purchases and SIPs for U.S. or Canada residents and keep redemption open. No Indian law bars it; the policy is theirs | Fund house limits |
| Treating NRO interest as tax-free | India exempts NRE interest while the holder is non-resident, but taxes NRO interest. The U.S. taxes worldwide interest, NRE included | Accounts |
| Believing TDS settles the Indian side | A non-resident whose total income, gains included, tops the basic exemption generally files an Indian return; excess TDS comes back only through one | TDS page |
| Assuming UK capital gains treatment | Unless the exact class has been on HMRC's list throughout, a gain is generally an offshore income gain taxed as income (20%, 40% or 45% in England for 2026-27), with no GBP 3,000 exemption | UK funds |
The Pencil-Margin Proofread
- Is every account on the list the form uses?
- Which measure does this form use: highest balance, year-end value, cost or proceeds?
- Which year is this one: calendar, UK or Indian?
- Which rate, from which source, on which date?
- What has the fund house changed since the move?
Rates and thresholds change yearly, the HMRC list monthly; the sources page says what to re-check.
Frequently asked questions
Is Form 8621 needed if my fund is not a PFIC?
PFIC status for Indian schemes rests on practitioner consensus; no IRS ruling names Indian funds, so the point is labelled not settled. The U.S. PFIC page explains the usual view.
Can tax offices see my Indian folio?
India's funds report folio values and payouts for holders abroad and U.S. persons each year (Form No. 166, due May 31). India shares reportable accounts with the IRS under FATCA and with partner countries, including Canada and the UK, under CRS.
What if I find a mistake after filing?
Routes differ. USA: before any IRS contact or investigation, a late FBAR goes through BSA E-Filing with the reason, and the IRS has procedures for late information returns. Canada: the Voluntary Disclosures Program may cover T1135 failures if conditions are met. UK: the Worldwide Disclosure Facility. Talk to a qualified adviser first.
Official sources
- IRS: Comparison of Form 8938 and FBAR requirements
- IRS: Instructions for Form 8621
- FinCEN: Report foreign bank and financial accounts
- GOV.UK: Approved offshore reporting funds
- Income Tax Department of India: Income tax returns FAQ
This page is a plain-language summary. The official source controls if there is any difference.