Deferring income with annuities

Annuity Cautions: Fees, Penalties and the NIIT

Cautions about annuities in plain English: surrender charges, market value adjustments, fees, the 3.8% NIIT, Illinois guaranty limits and what heirs receive.

Last reviewed November 6, 2026 · Figures as of November 6, 2026 · General information, not tax, legal or investment advice

General information only. Not tax, legal or investment advice. A planning idea named here is not a recommendation for any person. CPA Tax Payroll and Accounting Corp is a CPA firm, not a law firm. Tax rules change often and figures are for the tax year shown: confirm with the official source or a qualified adviser before you act. Read the full notice.

This page, part of our annuities group, is for readers who own, are offered or have inherited an annuity, and for advisers who review one. The rule in one sentence: an annuity's costs, exit charges and tax traps sit in the contract and the tax code, so they are worth reading before any decision. Our checklist is the Exit-Door Fine-Print Pass. General information, not a recommendation of any annuity.

Slide show: Annuity cautions in five slides

  1. Exit charges

    Surrender charges usually decline over a surrender period. Most such contracts allow free withdrawals, usually up to 10 percent a year.

  2. Market value adjustment

    It can raise or lower value on an early exit, often lowers it, and comes on top of surrender charges.

  3. Fees

    Variable annuities may charge mortality and expense fees (1.25 percent a year in an SEC example) plus fund and rider fees.

  4. Tax add-ons

    Gain is ordinary income. The 10 percent tax may apply before 59 1/2, and the NIIT at high income.

  5. Heirs

    No step-up in basis: the gain is income in respect of a decedent, untaxed income the owner left behind.

What the rule says

TopicPlain meaningSource label
NIIT3.8% of the lesser of net investment income or MAGI over the threshold; plan and IRA annuity payments are not net investment income but raise MAGIIRC 1411; Regs. 1.1411-1(d)(1), 1.1411-4, 1.1411-8
Guaranty limitsIllinois: $250,000 present value of annuity benefits per life, generally $300,000 in total. Variable subaccount values and uncredited index interest are not covered; sellers may not use the association to promote sales215 ILCS 5/531.03, 531.19
Premium taxIllinois excludes annuity premiums from its 0.5% insurer tax; other states may charge215 ILCS 5/409
Seller standardsIllinois rule on care, disclosure and conflicts (amended effective February 3, 2023); SEC Regulation BI for variable annuities and RILAs50 Ill. Adm. Code 3120; 17 CFR 240.15l-1
InheritedNo step-up. If the owner died before payouts: 5-year payout, life-expectancy payments starting within 1 year, or spousal continuationIRC 1014(b)(9), (c), 72(s); Rev. Rul. 2005-30

How it works in numbers

Invented 2026 joint return: wages $230,000, dividends $5,000, and a surrender of a non-qualified annuity worth $160,000 with $100,000 invested, so $60,000 is taxable.

ScenarioMAGINIIT
No surrender$235,000$0
$60,000 from a traditional IRA$295,000$190
$60,000 annuity gain$295,000$1,710

Annuity: 3.8% x the lesser of $65,000 or the $45,000 over the threshold is $1,710. IRA: only $5,000 is net investment income.

Planning points

  • People in this situation often tally the full exit cost before buying or exchanging: surrender charge, new surrender period, adjustment and lost riders. Illinois' exchange review also looks at any exchange in the prior 60 months.
  • They ask how the seller is paid, since the SEC warns of a financial incentive. Ask your adviser.
  • They check how a surrender gain lands in a high-income year: NIIT, Medicare IRMAA (the income-based premium surcharge) two years later, and the temporary senior deduction phase-out (2025 to 2028). See the NIIT guide.

The Exit-Door Fine-Print Pass

  • What does leaving cost in years 1, 5 and 10: surrender charge, free withdrawal, adjustment?
  • Which recurring fees apply: contract, fund, rider?
  • What can the insurer change?
  • What would a taxable gain do to NIIT and IRMAA?
  • Who inherits, and what basis do they get?

Figures that change each year: none here.

Frequently asked questions

How much does the Illinois guaranty association protect?

Up to $250,000 present value of annuity benefits per life, with the exclusions above.

Do heirs get a step-up in basis on an annuity?

No. See estate and gift basics for what does step up.

Do annuity gains trigger the NIIT?

For a non-qualified annuity, yes, above the threshold. See how annuity income is taxed.

Official sources

This page is a plain-language summary. The official source controls if there is any difference.