This page, part of our annuities group, is for owners of a non-qualified deferred annuity: a contract with an insurer bought with after-tax money, outside an IRA or 401(k). The rule in one sentence: growth is not taxed until money comes out, and then withdrawals take the gain out first, as ordinary income (regular rates, not capital gain rates). How deferred annuity income is taxed also turns on age and ownership, so the page ends with a short list, the Gain-Layer Peel Check. General information, not advice.
What the rule says
| Requirement | Plain meaning | Source label |
|---|---|---|
| Gain first | Taxed up to gain: cash value minus investment in the contract (after-tax premiums not yet returned). A full surrender is taxed only above investment | IRC 72(e) |
| 10 percent tax | On the taxable part before 59 1/2; exceptions include death, disability, equal payments for life, immediate annuities | IRC 72(q) |
| Loans, pledges, gifts | Treated as money received (gifts: contracts issued after April 22, 1987) | IRC 72(e); Pub. 575 |
| One-contract rule | Same insurer, owner and calendar year: added together | IRC 72(e)(12) |
| Non-natural owner | Generally taxed on yearly gain | IRC 72(u) |
How it works in numbers
Invented example. Maria, 52, paid a $100,000 premium; the contract is worth $140,000, so the gain is $40,000. She withdraws $30,000, all taxable because it is below the gain, plus a $3,000 extra 10 percent tax. Value is now $110,000, with $10,000 of gain left. Next year, at 53, she takes $25,000: $10,000 is taxable (extra tax $1,000) and $15,000 comes back untaxed.
Planning points
- People in this situation often consider whether money may be needed before 59 1/2, since gain-first taxation, the 10 percent tax and surrender charges can stack (see annuity cautions).
- They check how a taxable withdrawal fits the bracket. It also counts toward Social Security benefit taxation and, two years later, Medicare IRMAA, the income-based premium surcharge.
- They ask who owns the contract, since a corporate owner or a gift changes the result. Ask your adviser first.
The Gain-Layer Peel Check
- Compare premiums paid with cash value. The difference is the gain that comes out first.
- Any premiums paid before August 14, 1982? That part follows older basis-first treatment.
- Add together same-insurer contracts bought in one calendar year.
- Test age against 59 1/2 and the exceptions before the withdrawal.
- Match Form 1099-R (codes 1 or 2 for early amounts; code D flags possible net investment income tax) to Form 5329, or Schedule 2 line 8 (2025 form) in the simple case.
Figures that change each year: none here.
Frequently asked questions
Is annuity growth taxed every year?
Not for a person who owns it. A corporation or other non-natural owner is generally taxed yearly on the gain (IRC 72(u)), with exceptions such as plan or IRA contracts.
Are annuity gains taxed at capital gain rates?
No. They are ordinary income. See capital gains and losses for rates that do not apply.
Does the 10 percent tax apply to everyone under 59 1/2?
The section 72(q) list is short. The newer plan exceptions for emergencies, birth or adoption and disasters are not on it. Product type does not change the tax: see annuity types.
Official sources
- Cornell Law School: 26 U.S.C. 72, Annuities
- IRS: Publication 575, Pension and Annuity Income
- IRS: Instructions for Forms 1099-R and 5498
- SEC Investor.gov: Annuities
This page is a plain-language summary. The official source controls if there is any difference.