Deferring income with annuities

Fixed, MYGA, Indexed and Variable Annuities

Neutral guide to fixed, MYGA, fixed indexed, RILA and variable annuities: who bears investment risk, how interest is credited and why the tax rules match.

Last reviewed November 6, 2026 · Figures as of November 6, 2026 · General information, not tax, legal or investment advice

General information only. Not tax, legal or investment advice. A planning idea named here is not a recommendation for any person. CPA Tax Payroll and Accounting Corp is a CPA firm, not a law firm. Tax rules change often and figures are for the tax year shown: confirm with the official source or a qualified adviser before you act. Read the full notice.

This page, part of our annuities group, is for readers comparing annuity types and for advisers who explain them. An annuity is a contract with an insurer; a deferred one saves first and pays later. The types differ in who carries investment risk and how interest is credited, yet the tax rules are the same for all of them. The page ends with a list for sorting them out, the Risk-Holder Roll Call. Descriptions are neutral, not recommendations.

Slide show: Annuity types in five slides

  1. Immediate or deferred

    An immediate annuity usually starts income within a year of one payment. A deferred income annuity buys income from a set later date and is generally irreversible.

  2. Fixed and MYGA

    The insurer sets the interest. A MYGA (multi-year guaranteed annuity) is an industry label for a fixed contract with a guaranteed rate for a stated term, then a renewal rate.

  3. Fixed indexed

    Interest follows an index through a cap, participation rate or spread, and never falls below zero.

  4. RILA

    Credits follow an index and can be negative, usually within insurer-set limits such as a buffer or floor.

  5. Variable

    The owner picks fund-like subaccounts. Gains and losses have no set limit, and the owner bears market risk.

What the rules say

TopicPlain meaningSource label
Who bears lossFixed: the insurer. Variable: the owner. Indexed and RILA: shared, within a floor or bufferSEC; FINRA
Who regulatesFixed and indexed: state insurance departments. RILA and variable: also the SEC, with a prospectusSEC

How it works in numbers

Invented figures modeled on the SEC's indexed-annuity examples, credit on a $100,000 account for one year:

FeatureIndex changeCredit
75% participation+10%+7.5%, or $7,500
7% cap+12%+7%, or $7,000
3% spread+9%+6%, or $6,000
10% buffer (RILA)-12%-2%, or -$2,000
10% floor (RILA)-12%-10%, or -$10,000

Planning points

  • People in this situation often consider who absorbs a loss in a bad year and which numbers the insurer may reset: caps, participation rates or a MYGA renewal rate.
  • They weigh costs: variable annuities charge for mortality and expenses, funds and riders; fixed and indexed ones often carry implicit costs through credited rates and limits.
  • Riders add cost, and a withdrawal can cut a benefit by more than the amount taken.
  • Tax treatment is the same for any type; retirees weigh income needs first. Ask your adviser and read the contract.

The Risk-Holder Roll Call

  • Name the type in plain words: fixed, MYGA, fixed indexed, RILA or variable.
  • Who bears a loss, and where does the buffer or floor sit?
  • What can the insurer change: renewal rate, cap, participation rate, spread?
  • What does it cost: explicit fees, rider fees or limits on credits?
  • How do you exit: surrender period, free withdrawals, market value adjustment? See cautions and fees.

Figures that change each year: none here; each insurer sets and can reset crediting terms.

Frequently asked questions

Do indexed annuities earn stock market returns?

No. Caps, participation rates and spreads limit gains, dividends are usually left out, and surrender charges can reduce value.

Are variable annuity gains taxed as capital gains?

No. Gains are ordinary income, as for the other types.

Can an annuity be moved to another contract without current tax?

Sometimes, by a direct transfer under section 1035. See 1035 exchanges.

Official sources

This page is a plain-language summary. The official source controls if there is any difference.