This page is for fellow practitioners and for families who want to ask sharper questions of the adviser who reads these decisions for them. The rule in one sentence: a court decision binds only the courts and agencies that must follow it, and IRS guidance carries the weight of the place where it is published. The Citation Pedigree Pass at the end turns that into five questions. It opens our recent cases and rulings group. General information only.
What the rule says
| Source | What weight it has | Source label |
|---|---|---|
| Supreme Court decision | Binds every federal court | General principle |
| Published court of appeals opinion | Binds that circuit. Unpublished or nonprecedential orders bind no one beyond the parties. | General principle |
| Tax Court "T.C." opinion | Precedential. Appeal goes to the circuit where an individual lived or a corporation has its main place of business, unless both sides agree on another. The Tax Court follows an on-point ruling of that circuit (the Golsen rule). | IRC 7482(b); 167 T.C. No. 13 |
| Tax Court "T.C. Memo." opinion | Mainly applies settled law to facts. Not precedent. | IRM 4.10.7.2.8.2.3 |
| Small tax case ($50,000 or less per year) | Cannot be appealed. Not precedent. | IRC 7463 |
| Revenue ruling or procedure in the IRB | May be used as precedent. Lacks the force of a regulation. | IRB introduction |
| Private letter ruling, chief counsel advice | May not be cited as precedent. | IRC 6110(k)(3) |
| IRS FAQ | Not precedent. Good-faith reliance can support penalty relief. | IRS reliance page |
For penalties a different list applies. "Authority" for the substantial authority test includes the Code, regulations, revenue rulings, court cases, IRB notices and private letter rulings, but not treatises, articles or tax professionals' opinions (Treas. Reg. 1.6662-4(d)(3)(iii)). See the accuracy-related penalty.
The Citation Pedigree Pass
- Court or office: does it bind where the client lives? For Illinois, that is the Seventh Circuit.
- Label: published, memorandum, small case, nonprecedential order or written determination?
- Status: on appeal, reversed or withdrawn? The January 2026 Fifth Circuit opinion in K Alain was withdrawn.
- Regulation test: did the court read the statute for itself after Loper Bright?
- File note: date opened and official link saved.
Families can ask the same five questions of any adviser who cites a case. Figures that change each year: none here. Next see Supreme Court decisions, Tax Court decisions and tracking fast-moving guidance.
Frequently asked questions
Does Loper Bright mean Treasury regulations no longer bind?
No. It changed how courts review rules. Each rule stands or falls case by case, and earlier decisions that upheld agency action under Chevron keep their force.
Can a client rely on an IRS FAQ?
The IRS says FAQs are not precedent and the law controls if they differ. It also says good-faith, reasonable reliance can support relief from penalties with a reasonable-cause standard. Relief still depends on the facts. See reasonable cause relief.
Which court controls for an Illinois taxpayer?
The Seventh Circuit and the Supreme Court. The Tax Court follows an on-point ruling of the circuit where the case would be appealed, so another circuit's view is at most persuasive.
Official sources
- IRS: Taxpayer reliance on guidance in the Internal Revenue Bulletin and FAQs
- IRS: Understanding IRS guidance, a brief primer
- Cornell Law School: 26 U.S.C. 7482, Courts of review
- Cornell Law School: 26 U.S.C. 6110, Written determinations
- Supreme Court: Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, 603 U.S. 369 (2024)
This page is a plain-language summary. The official source controls if there is any difference.