This page, part of our recent cases and rulings group, is for taxpayers, owners and advisers who want to read recent Tax Court decisions correctly. The rule in one sentence: only the court's regular "T.C." opinions are precedent, and each is appealed to the circuit where the taxpayer lived or the company has its main place of business. The Label-and-Venue Walk-Through at the end applies that. Deadline and penalty opinions are on the penalty and procedure page; see also how to read tax rulings. General information only.
Regular opinions
| Case and citation | Court and date | What it held | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|---|
| JM Assets, LP v. Commissioner, 165 T.C. No. 1 | July 2, 2025; reviewed by the full court | Reg. 301.6235-1(b)(2)(A) is invalid where it extends the partnership adjustment period beyond the text of section 6235(a)(2). The adjustment was untimely. | A regulation struck after Loper Bright. No appeal on the docket. |
| Siemens Medical Solutions USA, Inc. v. Commissioner, 167 T.C. No. 5 | July 15, 2026; reviewed | The taxpayer gets the full section 245A dividends-received deduction. Temp. Reg. 1.245A-5T cannot override the clear statutory text. | Another regulation set aside. No appeal found. |
| Diversified Group Inc. v. Commissioner; Haber v. Commissioner, 166 T.C. No. 2 | February 23, 2026 | A declined IRS offer of an Appeals conference was a prior "opportunity to dispute" the section 6707 promoter penalties, barring that dispute in a collection due process hearing. The regulation upheld in Lewis survives Loper Bright. | Not final: the case continues. |
| Savage v. Commissioner; Torres v. Commissioner, 165 T.C. No. 5 | September 11, 2025; reviewed | For the section 199A W-2 wage limit, wages count only if deductible in computing qualified business income. Wages disallowed by section 280E (cannabis) do not count. | Appealed to the Ninth Circuit, December 9, 2025. Pending. |
| AbbVie Inc. & Subsidiaries v. Commissioner, 164 T.C. No. 10 | June 17, 2025 | Section 1234A did not turn a fee of about $1.6 billion for ending a merger cooperation agreement into a capital loss, because the agreement concerned services, not property. | Illinois case. The IRS dropped its Seventh Circuit appeal; the decision stands. |
| Eiler v. Commissioner, 167 T.C. No. 3 | July 14, 2026 | Fair Credit Reporting Act settlement proceeds, including the lawyers' share, are fully includible in income. The fees are not deductible in figuring adjusted gross income. | Appealed to the Ninth Circuit, October 6, 2026. Pending. |
Memorandum opinions ("T.C. Memo.") are not precedent. In White (T.C. Memo. 2026-56, June 29, 2026), Appeals abused its discretion by sustaining a levy on liabilities already settled through a Justice Department payment plan; it is on appeal to the Third Circuit.
The Label-and-Venue Walk-Through
- Label: regular "T.C." opinion, memorandum or summary opinion?
- Venue: where did the taxpayer live, or the company have its main place of business?
- Status: appealed, as with Savage and Eiler, or final?
- Scope: what did the court decide, and what did it leave for trial?
- Facts: how close are the client's facts?
Figures that change each year: none here. See section 199A and innocent spouse relief.
Frequently asked questions
Are Tax Court memorandum opinions precedent?
No. They mainly apply settled law to facts. Small tax case decisions ($50,000 or less in dispute per year) cannot be appealed and are not precedent either.
Where is a Tax Court decision appealed?
To the circuit of the individual's legal residence when the petition was filed, or the corporation's principal place of business, unless both sides agree in writing on another.
Is the Savage 199A decision settled law?
No. It is on appeal to the Ninth Circuit.
Official sources
- U.S. Tax Court: DAWSON search, Opinion tab
- U.S. Tax Court: JM Assets, LP v. Commissioner, docket 2531-24
- U.S. Tax Court: Savage v. Commissioner, docket 21606-22
- U.S. Tax Court: AbbVie Inc. v. Commissioner, docket 2597-23
- U.S. Tax Court: Siemens Medical Solutions v. Commissioner, docket 11432-25
This page is a plain-language summary. The official source controls if there is any difference.