This page, part of our recent cases and rulings group, is for taxpayers, owners and advisers who want to know how courts treated deadlines and penalties in recent cases. The rule in one sentence: deadlines and penalty procedures are decided statute by statute and sometimes circuit by circuit, so the habit to build is to file on time and keep the paper trail. The Calendar-First Drill at the end puts the dates first. General information only.
- Second Circuit, Buller: not jurisdictional, tollable
- Sixth Circuit, Oquendo: presumptively tollable
- Eighth Circuit, Maniktala: tollable, departing from its 1977 precedent
- First Circuit, Kyick: not jurisdictional, but no tolling
Source: circuit opinions
In circuits that have not ruled, the Tax Court still treats this deadline as jurisdictional. Where allowed, tolling needs diligence plus an extraordinary circumstance. Other deadlines go statute by statute:
- Kings Road Property (167 T.C. No. 11, September 21, 2026): the 90-day deadline to challenge a partnership adjustment (section 6234(a)) can be tolled, and was, because the IRS wrongly told counsel no notice had been mailed.
- North Wall Holdings (165 T.C. No. 9, October 21, 2025): no tolling of the TEFRA petition periods in section 6226.
- Belagio Fine Jewelry (164 T.C. No. 7, April 15, 2025): the worker-classification deadline (section 7436) can be tolled, but not here. A petition sent by FedEx Express Saver, not a designated delivery service, arrived a day late.
Penalty rulings
| Case and citation | Court and date | What it held | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|---|
| Swift v. Commissioner, No. 24-60270 | 5th Cir., July 16, 2025; published | Premiums paid to related micro-captive insurers were not insurance, so deductions were disallowed and penalties sustained. Supervisory approval of penalties (section 6751(b)) is timely if obtained before assessment, or before the supervisor loses discretion, if earlier. | Certiorari denied April 20, 2026. Battat (11th Cir., unpublished) applied an approval-before-assessment rule; denied April 27, 2026. |
| Patel v. Commissioner, 165 T.C. No. 10 | Tax Court, November 12, 2025 | A micro-captive arrangement lacked economic substance, and the section 6662(b)(6) penalty was sustained for 2014 to 2016. For 2014 and 2015 the 40 percent rate applied because disclosure was inadequate. | Appealed to the Fifth Circuit March 18, 2026. Pending. |
| Savannah Shoals, LLC v. Commissioner, No. 24-12661 | 11th Cir., July 16, 2026; published | The Tax Court valued a conservation easement at $480,000 against a claimed $23 million deduction. The 40 percent gross valuation misstatement penalty was affirmed. | Recent purchase prices drove the value. No Supreme Court filing found. |
| United States v. Schwarzbaum, No. 22-14058 | 11th Cir., January 23, 2025; published | Willful FBAR penalties are partly punitive, so the Excessive Fines Clause applies. The court struck $300,000 as grossly disproportional and upheld the rest, remanding for $12,255,813 plus interest and late fees. | Most of the penalty survived. No certiorari petition found. |
How it works in numbers
Invented example. A resident non-willfully missed foreign account reports for 3 years, with 8 accounts each year. The rejected per-account theory gives 3 x 8 x $10,000 = $240,000. Under Bittner it is 3 x $10,000 = $30,000 at most, and the IRS can assess less.
The Calendar-First Drill
- Count: which deadline governs, and when does it start?
- Circuit: does the client's circuit allow tolling?
- Delivery: designated service, with proof?
- Penalty file: who approved the penalty, and when?
- Support: valuation and disclosure records kept?
Figures that change each year: none here. See FBAR penalties, valuation penalties and the notice of deficiency.
Frequently asked questions
Can I file a late Tax Court petition and ask for tolling?
Not reliably. It depends on the statute and the circuit, so file on time.
Does Bittner cap FBAR penalties at $10,000 a year?
No. The rule is per report, for non-willful violations only. Check the current figure in 31 CFR 1010.821 before quoting one.
Are micro-captive insurance deductions illegal?
No. The cases turn on facts. January 2025 regulations make some arrangements listed transactions or transactions of interest, which triggers disclosure duties, not a ban.
Official sources
- Eighth Circuit: Maniktala v. Commissioner, No. 25-1366
- Second Circuit: Buller v. Commissioner, No. 24-1557
- Fifth Circuit: Swift v. Commissioner, No. 24-60270
- Eleventh Circuit: United States v. Schwarzbaum, No. 22-14058
- U.S. Tax Court: Kings Road Property, LLC v. Commissioner, docket 10272-25
This page is a plain-language summary. The official source controls if there is any difference.