This page is for fellow practitioners, and for families who want to know what to ask. If you advise clients, the cases in our recent cases and rulings group suggest habits more than rules. The rule in one sentence: a case is a lesson about records and timing, never a forecast of how your facts will come out. The Case-to-Checklist Bridge at the end turns the lessons into five checks. General information only.
From case to checklist
| Lesson | What advisers often do | Standard or source |
|---|---|---|
| Deadlines vary (Kyick, Belagio) | Calendar every deadline from the notice date; use a designated delivery service and keep proof | See penalty and procedure cases |
| Regulation-based positions can fail (3M, JM Assets) | Note the statute's text as well as the regulation; consider Form 8275-R for a position contrary to a regulation | Treas. Reg. 1.6662-4(e), (f) |
| Substance beats form (Liberty Global, Patel, Savannah Shoals) | Keep business-purpose, appraisal and disclosure records | IRC 6664(c)(2) |
| Partner roles matter (K Alain, Soroban) | Record who runs and manages the business; expect circuit differences | IRC 1402(a)(13) |
| Valuation counts (Connelly) | Ask an attorney and adviser how a buyout funded by company-owned insurance is valued | Estate and gift basics |
People who advise on these topics often date-stamp written advice, because it reflects the law as of its date, and an AICPA member has no duty to update it unless helping implement the plan or agreeing to (SSTS 3.1.5, 3.1.11). Circular 230 section 10.34(c) requires a practitioner to tell clients of penalties reasonably likely to apply and any chance to avoid them by disclosure.
For Illinois clients the Seventh Circuit matters most. Its published civil rulings in this period (Bachner, Daugerdas) mostly favored the IRS on collection and penalties.
How it works in numbers
Invented example. A taxpayer claims a section 199A deduction. The correct tax is $150,000 and the return shows $140,000, an understatement of $10,000. For a 199A claimant the substantial-understatement threshold is the greater of 5 percent of the correct tax ($7,500) or $5,000, so $7,500, and $10,000 exceeds it. A 20 percent accuracy-related penalty would be $2,000 unless substantial authority or adequate disclosure reduces the understatement. Without a 199A deduction the threshold would be 10 percent, or $15,000, so this understatement would not be substantial (negligence is tested separately).
The Case-to-Checklist Bridge
- Which case is the lesson from, and is it final or on appeal?
- Does the client's circuit follow it?
- What record would support the position if the IRS disagreed?
- Which deadline or penalty rule applies, and when does it start?
- Has the client been told what could change, with the date of the advice?
Figures that change each year: none here. Track new rulings with tracking fast-moving guidance.
Frequently asked questions
Does a case tell me how my own return will turn out?
No. Each ruling rests on its facts, its statute and its circuit. Ask your adviser about your situation; see tax planning.
Does a documentation file protect against penalties?
It can support a reasonable-cause or substantial-authority argument, but it does not promise relief. See the accuracy-related penalty.
Where are the cases summarized?
On the Supreme Court, appeals court and Tax Court pages.
Official sources
- IRS: Taxpayer reliance on guidance in the Internal Revenue Bulletin and FAQs
- Cornell Law School: 26 U.S.C. 6664, Reasonable cause exception
- eCFR: Treas. Reg. 1.6662-4, Substantial authority and disclosure
- eCFR: 31 CFR 10.34, Standards for returns and advice
- AICPA: Statements on Standards for Tax Services Nos. 1 to 4
This page is a plain-language summary. The official source controls if there is any difference.